On April 17, 2026, the United States Supreme Court ruled that Louisiana coastal pollution suits against Chevron and Exxon belong in federal court, not state court. The 8‑0 decision in Chevron USA Inc. et al. v. Plaquemines Parish, Louisiana, et al. vacated a 2‑1 Fifth Circuit ruling affirming the federal district court order sending the case to state court. Agreeing with Chevron that its oil production in Louisiana during World War II was federal in nature, the Court concluded that the case fit within the federal officer removal statute and thus must proceed in federal court. Because he owns stock in one of the energy companies involved, Justice Alito did not participate in the decision.
In 2013, Plaquemines Parish and other parishes filed 42 lawsuits against oil and gas companies for claims that the companies damaged wetlands and failed to obtain or comply with the proper permits. Among other things, the parishes criticized the companies for using vertical-drilling methods, canals, and earthen pits for their production operations during WWII.
Several defendants, including Chevron, promptly removed all of these lawsuits to federal court, including at least some under the federal officer removal statute. In the two suits before the Court, Chevron asserted that its WWII production activities on the lands at issue were for it then to refine into aviation fuel (avgas) under contracts it had with the federal government for its war efforts. But all the lawsuits were subsequently remanded back to state court. In one of the cases before the Court, a Plaquemines Parish jury in a three week trial in 2025 sided with the parish and awarded a $745 million verdict against Chevron and two other companies. Meanwhile, Chevron and other defendants had appealed the remand orders to the Fifth Circuit, which in a 2‑to‑1 decision affirmed the district court’s remand orders. By a vote of 7‑to‑6, the Fifth Circuit denied en banc rehearing.
The Supreme Court in Chevron considered whether claims brought by Louisiana parishes alleging environmental damage from, among other things, oil production activities during WWII could be removed from state to federal court under the federal officer removal statute. At the center of Chevron was exactly how broadly to read the phrase “for or relating to” in the federal officer removal statute. 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a)(1) permits removal where a suit is “for or relating to” acts performed under federal authority. Chevron and Exxon argued that, by upholding the remand orders to state court, the Fifth Circuit wrongly relied on an outdated legal test for the federal officer removal statute.
Writing for the Court, Justice Thomas held that Chevron satisfied the “relating to” requirement of the federal officer removal statute by plausibly alleging a close, non-attenuated connection between its challenged WWII crude-oil production practices and its federally directed duty to refine avgas for the U.S. military. The Court emphasized that much of the crude from the relevant Louisiana fields fed Chevron’s avgas refining, that using vertical-drilling methods helped increase production, that using canals instead of building roads resulted in more timely oil production, and that using earthen pits complied with government directives to preserve steel, and thus that all these actions the parishes were asserting as improper aligned with wartime directives to maximize fuel for the war effort. The Fifth Circuit’s stricter approach requiring contracts to specify how crude would be obtained was rejected as too narrow for the statute’s “relating to” language.
What to Take Away from the Court’s Chevron Decision:
- Forum Shift: Moving these suits to federal court can reshape litigation strategy, timelines, and potentially outcomes in Louisiana’s long-running coastal use disputes under the State and Local Coastal Resources Management Act.
- Broader Removal Pathway: Defendants acting under federal direction, especially in national security or wartime contexts, may have a more direct path to federal court where their challenged conduct bears a close connection to federal duties, even if contracts did not outline specific operational methods.
But a quick note: The Court’s decision in Chevron is not a ruling on the merits. The Supreme Court addressed only removability, not liability. Although major Louisiana cases over coastal erosion are now positioned for federal adjudication, the decision does not resolve whether the companies in other cases can satisfy the ’”for or relating to” requirement for removal. Nor does it address the other requirements of federal officer removal. Nor does it decide that a defendant cannot be liable for any erosion to the extent its production activities at issue aligned with government directives to increase and quicken crude oil production and preserve steel. Instead, the decision simply vacates the Fifth Circuit’s judgment and remands the case for further proceedings consistent with its opinion.
The Court did not mention the $745 million state court jury verdict rendered while the appeal of the remand order was making its way to the Supreme Court. But the Court’s holding that remand to state court was improper appears to require the case to be retried in federal district court.
